Tax-Advantaged Retirement Investment Planning
Tax-advantaged retirement savings plans
You may have the opportunity to make investments into both individual retirement accounts (IRA) and into employer or self-employed tax-advantaged retirement plans, such as a 401k, 403b, 457, Keogh, Simple, or other employer sponsored retirement plan. In general, if your net wage and salary earnings after living expenses will provide enough free cash flow, most retirement investment advisers would recommend that you make the full contributions each year into both individual retirement accounts and employer tax-advantaged retirement investment plans throughout your years of employment up to when you retire.
Even when you find that your annual contributions to such individual and employer sponsored retirement plans would not reduce your current annual income subject to current income taxation, very often it still makes long-term retirement financial planning sense to make these IRA and employer plan contributions, since future appreciation of your tax-advantaged assets would be sheltered from ongoing taxation.
Academic studies also indicate that it usually only takes a few years of non-taxed investment growth within tax-advantaged retirement plans to overcome the 10% federal penalty for withdrawals before age 59 and 1/2. For the vast majority of people, it tends to be unlikely that they would need emergency access to these tax-advantaged assets in the few year period before their tax savings would reach the break-even point versus this potential early withdrawal penalty. Thus, from a variety of points-of-view, maximizing available tax-advantaged plan contributions year after year tends to be a better lifetime financial planning strategy.
Tax-advantaged retirement savings plan rules are complex
The complexity of US income tax rules related to individual retirement account and defined contribution employer sponsored retirement plans simply cannot be understated. The highly complex and confusing retirement investment tax mess that Congress has developed over time for US citizens to cope with is simply idiotic. Nevertheless, it is what it is, and all you can do is to try to understand the rules and to optimize your retirement investment strategy within these rules.
The best way to understand these topics yourself is to download Publications 560 and 590 from the IRS website. These tax publications are long and involved, so grab some coffee and dedicate a few hours to the task of learning about US retirement plan taxation. Grab some aspirin, if needed, but keep at it.
This can be a very valuable expenditure of your time, particularly if you have ever asked these questions: “how much do I need to save for retirement?” or “how long will my money last in retirement?” It does not take much reflection to realize that the answer to these questions would depend greatly upon whether your retirement savings account assets are “pre-tax” or “after-tax.” The pre-tax or after-tax income tax status of your retirement portfolio can make a huge difference in determining how much to save for retirement!
For those of you who are self-reliant and would like to find the answers for yourself, you really need an automated retirement savings calculator and retirement income calculator with sophisticated saving for retirement calculator functionality including fully integrated lifetime retirement tax calculator capabilities. (Here is a hint: poke around on the blue pull-down menu bar of this website, and you will find just what you need right here. The VeriPlan retirement planning software integrates, automates and hides these complex US tax-advantaged retirement investment plan rules, allowing you to stop guessing and to focus on making more optimal lifetime financial planning decisions.)
Traditional tax-advantaged employer sponsored plan and IRA contributions versus Roth retirement account investments
The multi-page article that follows provides information that will allow you to understand better the trade-offs between “traditional” and “Roth” tax-advantaged retirement accounts. Understanding the trade-offs between traditional IRA and 401k retirement contributions versus Roth 401k retirement plan contributions and Roth IRA contributions requires automated analysis of all the factors over one’s lifetime that impact this decision. Back-of-the-envelope calculations can easily be simplistic, incorrect, and deceptive. This decision can only properly be made with the assistance of a comprehensive retirement plan calculator tool.
If you do not have access to an IRA retirement calculator, 401k retirement calculator, or other retirement fund calculator that can do this analysis for you, you really should acquire such a retirement planning software tool. The dollar amounts involved can be very large over a lifetime, and the best retirement calculator can help you to determine the advantages of one choice over another. Following uninformed instincts and assumptions could lead you to pursue a highly sub-optimal retirement savings plan, and over your lifetime you might accumulate many, many thousands of dollars less than you could have saved with a more optimal tax-advantaged retirement investment strategy.
Generally, for the projected lifetime financial circumstances of the majority of Americans, a retirement plan calculator tool would develop lifetime projections indicating that it would be more advantageous to make contributions into traditional tax-advantaged retirement accounts rather that into Roth tax-advantaged retirement accounts. This tends to be true, whenever a person saving for retirement can take advantage of the current tax deductibility features of traditional tax-advantaged IRA, 401k and other retirement account investments. However, note that when retirement savers cannot a) take advantage of current tax deductibility to reduce their current taxable income and b) their earned income and cash flow still allows for some level of retirement plan contributions, then Roth contributions are preferred, if the tax rules allow the person to make Roth retirement plan contributions.
While a sophisticated and automated retirement plan calculator tool usually indicates that retirement savers should prefer to make traditional retirement plan contributions (versus Roth contributions) to reduce current taxable income, you should monitor the situation each year to understand the rules in effect in a particular tax year. Unfortunately, while tax-advantaged retirement plan account rules are already complex, some of the rules have been shifting from year to year. You need to keep paying attention to maintain an optimal tax-advantaged retirement savings plan strategy.
The following pages of this multi-page retirement financial planning article will provide some very useful information allowing you to understand better the trade-offs between “traditional” and “Roth” tax-advantaged retirement accounts. A subsequent article also discusses the estate planning and inheritance advantages of Roth retirement savings accounts, which can be very substantial, if your assets are likely to out-live you.
Retirement planning calculator software is highly recommended, when you want to develop a superior family financial strategy
This free “steps to financial freedom” site publishes articles regarding how to establish a do-it-yourself personal finance plan
The personal finance plan essays on this free website supply important thoughts about financial planning strategy topics that you may wish to consider. Our publications can help you in your efforts to establish a high quality, full life personal financial planning strategy. In addition, to produce a fully comprehensive long-term money management strategy depends upon you using superior financial planning software with the top investment planning software and the leading financial planning tools.
This free financial freedom online website also enables you to find the best ALL-IN-ONE financial calculators tool set, which includes the top retirement planning calculators program, high quality life time personal budget software, and the best investing calculator for your self-directed lifetime financial planning.
Personal Financial Planning Software for Individuals
- Investment Risk Tolerance Questionnaire (Investors with different appetites for investment risk tolerance are more satisfied with investment portfolio risk exposures that are more in line with their ability to cope with investment financial risk and rewards.
Investors who are more risk-averse are more satisfied with a less risky investment asset allocation – regardless of lower expected investment returns or the [...])
- About (
About the author
Lawrence J. Russell is the author of this website and the books offered through this website. He is also the architect and developer of the VeriPlan software discussed on this website. He holds a BS from M.I.T. (1975), MA from Brandeis University (1979), and MBA from Stanford University (1982). Larry is a former [...])
- VeriPlan Overview 4: Your Investment Portfolio Projections (VeriPlan Retirement Investment Calculator Overview: Part 4 of 7
Your investment portfolio and assets in VeriPlan
For each of your current investment portfolio asset holdings, the VeriPlan investment calculator software collects information about your share ownership amounts, values per share, investment costs, account taxability, and expected taxable capital gains distributions. The VeriPlan financial investment calculator automatically projects [...])
- The Value of Future versus Current Consumption (These are some thoughts that I provided to a client couple struggling to live within their means, while also saving and investing for their future:
The most important long-term topic we discussed was how you as a couple can find a way to balance current consumption, which presently exceeds your dual incomes, against the need to [...])
- Investment Risk and Return (Lifetime trade-offs between investment portfolio risk and investment returns
When making personal finance and retirement planning decisions, individuals must confront the dilemma that, historically, more conservative portfolio investments have yielded substantially lower investment returns than the returns that riskier investments have delivered. With either lower or higher risk-adjusted market return strategies, you simply cannot have your [...])
- Best Investment Strategy (Personal investing seems incredibly complex, but the best investment strategy also tends to be a more simple investment strategy
The complexity of personal investment management is driven by the nature of investing in securities that have uncertain and unknowable future values. Nobody -- amateur or professional -- has a working crystal ball that can predict future [...])
- Annual Tax Calculator (VeriPlan estimates your lifetime annual taxes in 8 different tax categories
The VeriPlan tax planning calculator projects your lifetime annual tax payments in 8 different tax categories. VeriPlan's fully integrated and automated lifetime annual tax calculator and retirement tax calculator capabilities automatically project your lifetime estimated taxes in these 8 tax categories:
Federal income taxes on earned [...])
- What should your lifetime IRA, 401k, and Roth contribution strategies be? (VeriPlan helps you to decide what your lifetime IRA, 401k, Roth IRA, and Roth 401k contribution strategy should be
With IRA, 401k, and other tax-advantaged retirement investment portfolio accounts, you trade off the relative value of paying federal income taxes, state income taxes, and local income taxes now versus paying them either later or never. The [...])
- VeriPlan Overview 1: Personal Finance Decisions (VeriPlan Overview: Part 1 of 7
Improving personal finance decisions with VeriPlan
VeriPlan gives you significant personal insight into your most important personal finance and investment portfolio decisions. Through comprehensive and customized lifetime projections, VeriPlan's integrated financial calculators and investment calculators model your particular financial situation across your adult lifetime. VeriPlan projects fully integrated scenarios about your income, [...])
- Roth Estate Planning Strategies (Roth IRA and Roth 401k Accounts and Roth Estate Planning Strategies
There are trade-offs when deciding whether to allocate contributions to Roth retirement savings accounts versus traditional retirement savings accounts that have deferred income taxation features. In the majority of personal finance situations, making 100% of allowable contributions to Roth retirement plans would probably not yield [...])
- VeriPlan Overview 7: Satisfaction Guarantee, Documentation, and Household License (VeriPlan Overview: Part 7 of 7
VeriPlan financial software satisfaction guarantee, licensing, documentation, and system platform information
All of VeriPlan's worksheets provide extensive and readily available documentation. A separate manual about VeriPlan's personal financial management software and investment growth calculator features is not necessary, because all necessary instructions are in the software where you need them. Nevertheless, the [...])
- 2014-01: January 2014 What Works in Personal Finance Newsletter (
- How to Use the VeriPlan Comprehensive Financial Planner (Developing a Family Financial Plan with VeriPlan
VeriPlan is personally customizable financial planning software that helps you develop your own comprehensive lifetime financial and investment plan for your family. Functioning as financial decision support software, it automates millions of integrated projection calculations behind the scenes. With VeriPlan you can improve your financial decision-making, because you are [...])
- Evaluating Roth IRA Conversions (Evaluating Roth IRA Conversions
This is the second part of a three-part article on Roth conversions, including information about Roth IRA conversion calculators and Roth IRA investment calculators. This article could help you to make a more informed decision about your family's Roth investment strategy. Key to you making a better decision about your lifetime Roth [...])
- Cash Asset Allocation (VeriPlan's investment growth calculator helps you to understand the projected value of your cash assets across your lifetime
To develop your lifetime projections, the VeriPlan compound investment calculator allows you to enter as many as 24 separate cash and cash equivalent asset holdings. For each of your current cash holding in your investment portfolio, you can [...])
- VeriPlan Overview 6: Ten Automated Lifetime and Retirement Calculator Tools (VeriPlan Overview: Part 6 of 7
VeriPlan's 10 financial planning tools and retirement planning calculators
Retirement Planning Calculator Tool:
With this retirement planning tool, you can set individual retirement ages for Earners 1 and 2. You can select whether or not to retire simultaneously. You can also adjust your expected ordinary living expense budget in retirement and the [...])
- Lifetime Investment Fees (Use a long term investment calculator to understand the lifetime costs of excessive investment fees
High mutual fund fees and other excessive investment fees are huge problems for the average individual investor. These excessive investment fees are the major factor that undermines the financial welfare of millions of Americans. The potential value of your investment portfolio [...])
- Economic ETF trade size cost considerations (Economic ETF trading size considerations
This article discusses some considerations regarding efficient ETF trading and economic trade sizes. At the end of this section, you will also find two tables on ETF brokerage and trading cost amortization over 1, 3, 5, 10, and 20 year holding periods. There is one table on do-it-yourself ETF discount brokerage [...])
- VeriPlan Lifetime Financial Planner — Annual Version Enhancements (2014 VeriPlan financial planning worksheet enhancements
The 2014 version focused on taxation and parameter updates:
1) Updated US Federal and 50 state + DC tax rates, limits, phaseouts, and other tax parameters using the latest information available. Updated tax information related to traditional and Roth tax-advantaged IRA and employer-sponsored retirement plan contributions and withdrawals.
2) Updated user adjustable [...])
- Asset Allocation Calculator (Understand how your lifetime investment asset allocation strategy would affect the growth of your financial asset portfolio
Your tolerance for investment risk is a relative concept -- rather than an absolute concept. Your tolerance for investment risk is relative to the investment risk tolerance of all other investors. Few people like investment risk, but some can [...])
PERSONAL FINANCE SOFTWARE | Retirement tax optimization strategy »