Does it matter how financial planners and investment advisors are paid?

Yes, it can matter significantly how a financial advisor is paid.

The heart of the compensation issue is an advisor’s potential “conflict of interest” with respect to payments from third parties. Does third party compensation change the quality of the recommendations that the advisers make? If an advisor works on sales commissions or accepts other third party payments, will he still provide the best recommendations based solely on the client’s best interests?

The Skilled Investor believes that the great majority of advisors are ethical. They work to manage properly the conflicts of interest associated with third party compensation that most advisors receive. Many objective, competent, and ethical practitioners are doing excellent jobs for their clients – no matter what their source of compensation.

Fee-only advisors, receive compensation directly and solely from their clients. Other advisors receive compensation from third parties. Some may receive both. When choosing an advisor, individuals should first decide the type of advisor compensation that makes them most comfortable. (For information on the different types of advisor compensation, see: Financial planner and investment advisor compensation paid by clients and Financial planner and investment advisor compensation paid by third parties)

However, the problem for individual investors is not the ethical majority of practitioners. The problem is the ethically challenged minority.

The heart of the conflict of interest issue is whether a client can tell the difference between an ethical practitioner who “just happens to be paid by third parties” versus an unethical advisor to whom the client’s interests are secondary.

As you might expect, substantial controversy exists within the advisory industry about which forms of advisor payment are better for the client. Fee-only advisors argue that they have absolutely no conflict of interest in their obligation toward their clients. Assuming that a fee-only advisor is competent and diligent, a client can reasonably expect that the advisor’s recommendations will be objective and in the client’s best interests. Fee-only advisors say that commissioned advisors are just disguised salespersons.

Advisors who accept various forms of third party compensation insist that they can be objective. They also contend that they still can and do offer the best products to their clients.

Some commissioned advisors suggest that they are more motivated to meet clients’ needs. They say that their advice costs nothing, unless the client acts on a recommendation. Commissioned advisors may say that fee-only advisors are too disinterested, because they are paid whether or not a client acts upon their advice. They also argue that a client will still have to pay a transaction charge, if he were to go elsewhere to make the recommended purchase. Note that the size of the transaction charge is the crux of the issue, as well as the ongoing charges. See: Excessive investment costs are a huge problem for individual investors

Note also that conflict of interest relates only to suboptimal advisor recommendations and to associated actions that confuse fiduciary priorities. Clients will still receive legitimate financial products for their money. These products just might not be the best or the most cost effective product available.

More severe ethical shortcomings involve outright fraud. Such actions are not the subject of this article. For more information on protecting oneself from advisor fraud, see:

• Avoiding financial planning and investment advisor frauds and scams – Overview
• Avoiding advisor frauds and scams – The “Never-do” list, Part 1
• Avoiding advisor frauds and scams – The “Never-do” list, Part 2
• Avoiding advisor frauds and scams – The “Never-do” list, Part 3

________________________________________________
Also, see these related articles on advisor compensation:

• Fee-only compensation aligns the interests of clients and their financial advisors
• Fee-only financial planner and investment advisory groups
• The securities industry calls marketing and selling “advising”
• Many investors are not fooled by an ethically challenged securities industry

Tags: financial planning

Personal Financial Planning

• The Kind of Financial Advisor You Need ( The kind of financial advisor you need - A Tip from The Skilled Investor Good or bad, financial advisors are expensive. If you need a financial advisor's help and you carefully select a good financial advisor, the value of the personal finance and investment advice that you receive might easily repay the advisor cost. However, bad [...])
• Financial Articles and Personal Finance Advice from Personal Finance Blogs – October 11 2008 ( Carnival of Financial Planning - October 11 2008 Edition Welcome to the October 11, 2008 edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning. The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus on efficient and sustainable personal financial planning practices that can lead to lifetime financial security. This [...])
• Can you really beat the stock market? ( You are not likely to beat the stock market, despite all the cheer leading from the securities industry and the financial media. When you try to beat the public securities markets, unfortunately you are more likely to trail the market’s return, because of extra costs, taxes, and investment mistakes. The idea that investors can beat the market [...])
• How Expensive is Investment Advisor Compensation Paid via Sales Loads? ( Even if you actually are getting good financial advice, paying your investment advisor via a sales load charge is just one of several potential compensation methods. A sales load might be the method that you prefer to compensate your broker or advisor. If your advisor is truly competent and ethical, he may be able to manage [...])
• Avoid High Turnover Mutual Funds and Active ETF Trading ( Avoid investment funds with higher investment portfolio turnover The problem with high turnover is that higher fund trading adds substantial hidden expenses that drag down returns. Because short-term trading is a zero sum game (before costs) played against other well informed traders, greater turnover is far more likely on average to result in lower fund returns instead [...])
• Fund Authority Scores for Stock ETFs and Mutual Funds – Management expenses, sales loads, and trading cost factors ( Fund Authority Scores range from -10 to +10 and measure five factors for diversified stock or equity investment funds: 1) annualized management and sales expenses, 2) trading costs, 3) historical performance, 4) fund maturity, and 5) operating efficiency. Go to Part 2 -->> This article explains how Fund Authority Scores rate stock or equity mutual funds and [...])
• Fund Authority Scores for Stock ETFs and Mutual Funds – Fund maturity and operating efficiency ( Fund Authority Scores rate mutual funds and ETFs on the most important economic factors affecting long term diversified stock or equity investment fund performance. This article explains the investment fund maturity and operating efficiency factors. <<-- Go to Part 2 Parts 1 and 2 of this article discussed the first three, most heavily weighted factors used in [...])
• Mutual Fund and ETF Screening Requirements ( On-line screening of mutual funds and ETFs: minimum requirements In this article, The Skilled Investor discusses minimum requirements for on-line mutual fund and ETF screening tools. This article summarizes our seven scientifically based fund selection criteria and reports on our survey of the capabilities of free on-line website tools to do screens using these criteria. Automated fund [...])
• American Funds – Capital World Growth and Income Fund – Class A Shares (CWGIX) warrant a +2 Fund Authority Score (Fund Authority Scores rate mutual funds and exchange traded funds (ETFs) on the most important economic factors that influence individual investors' net long term diversified investment fund performance. The Skilled Investor developed the Fund Authority Score system to provide individual investors with concise and objective summaries of mutual funds and ETFs for comparisons within investment [...])
• The Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years – Part 3 (< <-- Go to Part 2 The Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years - Part 3 There is no reason to believe that industry self-regulation or governmental regulation will ever fix these problems. Only those individuals who become wise enough to be proactive and seek out lower cost financial products will stop getting fleeced. [...])
• Financial Articles and Personal Finance Advice from Personal Finance Blogs – November 22 2008 ( Carnival of Financial Planning - November 22 2008 Edition Welcome to the November 22, 2008 edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning. The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus on efficient and sustainable personal financial planning practices that can lead to lifetime financial security. This [...])
• October 4 2007 Edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning ( Carnival of Financial Planning - October 4, 2007 Edition Welcome to the October 4, 2007 edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning. The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus on efficient and sustainable personal financial planning practices that can lead to lifetime financial security. This [...])