How to distinguish between true investment skill and luck
Even if an investor has obtained superior results over an extended period, is this sufficient proof that these investment results were actually due to skill rather than just a lucky streak?
No, these investment results could still be due to chance. For example, take a large population, such as all individual investors in the U.S., and have each person perform a random chance operation like flipping a coin repeatedly. After many repetitions, a small portion of the population could appear to have remarkable results.
After 10 consecutive coin flips, some investors probably would have flipped 10 heads in a row (HHHHHHHHHH). If each head were to indicate a consecutive win in the stock market, that person might seem like an investment genius. However, ten heads in a row is no more or less likely than any other particular sequence of heads and tails. The person who flipped THTTHTTHHH has a sequence that is just as unique as 10 heads in a row. The person who flipped THTTHHTHHH, which is different only on the sixth coin toss, also has an equally unique sequence. However, to many people, these sequences of heads and tails would not appear to be nearly as exceptional as 10 heads in a row, even though the really are.
Repeated investment success may still be the result of luck rather than skill.
While it may appear that the person who got 10 heads in a row did something remarkable, it just appears to be more unusual, because the results were all the same. In a similar vein, if a large population of investors were each to choose investment securities at random and were to do this repeatedly, the results will be purely accidental. However, those who happened to pick securities with better results might seem like geniuses.
Given human propensities, you could almost guarantee that the longer the sequence of their accidental winners, the more the chests of these lucky winners would inflate with pride. They would probably also become increasingly vocal. The fact that they are no more or less likely to be a winner in the next round than any other participant, might be lost on them and anyone who hears their story, until the results of the next round are known. In addition, even if they lose the next round, they may conveniently not report their loss. Too many lucky throws of the investment dice and these persons could be absolutely insufferable at cocktail parties. (See: Can you really beat the securities markets? and Chance creates the illusion that investors can beat the stock market)
Only if an investor makes numerous specific predictions over time about WHY the prices of various securities will move in particular directions and those predictions come true far more often than not, can investment skill rather than dumb luck be demonstrated.
Because long-term success may still be due to random chance, there needs to be more stringent criteria for judging true investment skill. True skill might be demonstrated by two methods:
- An investor with superior skill could have a better understanding of what known information means and could use trading strategies to capitalize upon that better understanding. For example, such an investor might be better at using published accounting information to identify companies whose default risks would in fact turn out to be different from what others judge them to be. If such an investor made a large majority of such accurate selections, then it would be more probable that this analyst demonstrated superior skill.
- An investor with superior skill might be a better prognosticator of what is likely to happen in the future. In this case, the investor would make specific prior predictions about things that would happen. A higher degree of accuracy on specific predictions would be a way to identify an investor with skill.
Both of these potential sources of verifiable skill have a common element, which is the specificity of their predictions. Not only must an investor with skill call the direction of price movements, he must also predict why the price will move with a reasonably high degree of factual precision. If an investor predicts that a security will perform exceptionally well for specific reasons, and it does perform well, but for reasons that have nothing to do with his predictions, then this is still a chance result and not skill. (See: The illusion of superior professional investment manager performance)
The future unfolds unpredictably, and just because it turns out one way or another does not make an individual investor a genius or a fool.
An investor can only properly claim to be an investment genius when the proof is indisputable over a very long history of precise predictions of what would happen. Moreover, as with soothsayers and charlatans, it does not count to predict accurately a few times in the midst of a very large number of inaccurate predictions. Certain investors have received substantial acclaim because they once accurately called and acted upon a turn in the market, while their other erroneous predictions were forgotten.
Note also that an investor is not necessarily a fool if the future happens to unfold differently than he predicted. His assessment of opportunities and risks may have been reasonable at the time he made his judgment. However, what he may have been concerned about might not have materialized because other factors became more dominant. An investor is only a fool, if he convinces himself that he can predict the future, when he does not have a specific record of accomplishment as evidence. Investors who have been lucky and become over confident because of their past luck can become very dangerous to their own future financial welfare.
Tags: coin toss
Personal Financial Planning
- The Value and Opportunity Cost of Your Personal Investment Management Time (
Your time is valuable, and it should be included in calculations about your investment returns.
Whether you add or subtract value from your assets when you spend time on investment activities should also be evaluated. Some investors spend significant time on the wrong strategies. Instead of adding value, their efforts reduce their investment portfolio performance and [...])
- Commentary on How Many Mutual Funds are Needed for a Well-Diversified Portfolio (
For holding periods of many years, diversification improves dramatically, when you hold multiple actively-managed mutual funds in an investment portfolio.
In "How Many Mutual Funds Constitute a Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolio?," Professor Edward O'Neal of the University of New Hampshire at Durham tackled the important question of how much an investor could improve on diversification by [...])
- The Heavy Burden of Recurring Investment Expenses and Fees (
The heavy burden of recurring investment fees (Part 1 of 2)
Recurring investment costs can significantly impact the long-term value of your retained investment portfolio assets.
Recurring fees, such as asset management fees, 12b-1 marketing fees, and advisory/asset custody fees are charged periodically, as a percent of your investment assets. The relative cost-efficiency of your investment portfolio [...])
- Reduce investment expenses and control taxation – Step 7 of 10 Financial Planning Steps in the Right Direction (CLICK HERE TO READ THE SKILLED INVESTOR's OTHER ARTICLES ABOUT THESE "10 FINANCIAL PLANNING STEPS IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION
Even with optimal investment strategies, there is still substantial room to improve upon net investment performance through continued and vigilant focus on controlling investment costs and tax realization.
The fees extracted by the financial securities industry increased substantially [...])
- How unstable have stock market returns been over time? (Common stock equity market returns have varied widely in the past. The common stock equity risk premium has averaged about 4.1% from 1872 to 2000.
The equity risk premium is the equity market return less the risk free rate of return. The risk free rate of return includes both the inflation rate and the risk free [...])
- Vanguard 500 Index Fund – VFINX – merits the Best +10 Fund Authority Score (The Standard & Poors 500 stock index is the most common equity index fund benchmark in the U.S. The S and P 500 tracks about 75% of publicly traded U.S. equity market asset value. The dominant issue in choosing among passively managed index mutual funds and ETF funds benchmarked against the S & P 500 [...])
- Avoid High Turnover Mutual Funds and Active ETF Trading (Avoid investment funds with higher investment portfolio turnover
The problem with high turnover is that higher fund trading adds substantial hidden expenses that drag down returns.
Because short-term trading is a zero sum game (before costs) played against other well informed traders, greater turnover is far more likely on average to result in lower fund returns instead [...])
- Objective Personal Finance Answers Are Hard to Find (The Problem - Straight answers about personal financial planning and investment management are difficult to find
In this article, The Skilled Investor summarizes some of the significant problems faced by ordinary individuals, when they attempt to plan their family finances. This is the first in a series of articles that will provide scientifically grounded decision rules [...])
- The Quality and Cost of Advice Paid by Investment Sales Loads (Can you really get free and objective investment advice, when you pay investment sales loads?
Excessive investment expenses are one of the most significant barriers to your family's lifelong financial security.
Excessive investment costs are a plague on your personal financial planning. While financial services industry sales people tell you that you need to pay more to [...])
- Vanguard Total International Stock Index Fund (VGTSX) lands a +9 Fund Authority Score (The Vanguard Total International Stock Index mutual fund is a low cost alternative for broad, passive index investing internationally. This fund is a composite of three other Vanguard international funds: the Vanguard European Stock Index Fund (55.7%), the Vanguard Pacific Stock Index Fund (24.1%), and the Vanguard Emerging Markets Stock Index Fund (20.2%). The percentages [...])
- Advisor Costs and Strategies Determine Your Return on their Services (Financial advisor costs and the value of their investment strategies determine your return on investment from these investment advisor services
A previous financial article, “The Solution - ONLY follow financial strategies that are scientific, passive, diversified, savings focused, risk controlled, low cost, and tax efficient,” suggested that investors are much better off with a well-considered financial [...])
- The Optimal Investment Strategy for Individual Investors (The Solution - ONLY follow financial strategies that are scientific, passive, diversified, savings focused, risk controlled, low cost, and tax efficient
A previous article, "The Problem - Straight answers about personal financial and investment planning are difficult to find," summarized important reasons why individuals may experience difficulties, even if they are intent upon doing better with [...])
- Mutual Fund and ETF Screening Requirements (
On-line screening of mutual funds and ETFs: minimum requirements
In this article, The Skilled Investor discusses minimum requirements for on-line mutual fund and ETF screening tools. This article summarizes our seven scientifically based fund selection criteria and reports on our survey of the capabilities of free on-line website tools to do screens using these criteria.
Automated fund [...])
- The Kind of Financial Advisor You Need (
The kind of financial advisor you need - A Tip from The Skilled Investor
Good or bad, financial advisors are expensive. If you need a financial advisor's help and you carefully select a good financial advisor, the value of the personal finance and investment advice that you receive might easily repay the advisor cost. However, bad [...])
- Vantagepoint 500 Stock Index mutual fund Class II Shares (VPSKX) rate a +9 Fund Authority Score (Here is some really good news for you. The Skilled Investor has published an article about lower cost S&P 500 index mutual funds that you can read, entitled: Low Cost S&P 500 Index Mutual Funds. The Standard & Poors 500 stock index is the most common equity index fund benchmark in the U.S. The S [...])
Comments are closed.