Never invest solely because of superior past mutual fund or ETF performance
Superior past fund performance does NOT predict superior future performance.
Summary: A previous article, “The Solution – ONLY follow financial strategies that are scientific, passive, diversified, savings focused, risk controlled, low cost, and tax efficient,” suggested that individuals are much better off with a well-considered financial viewpoint. A stable set of financial beliefs can help you to keep focused and on track throughout your life. This follow-up article discusses why you should not invest solely because of superior past performance.
Only very poor past performance tends to be a slight predictor of more poor performance in the future, and excessive investment costs are the likely culprit. Many individual investors rush around buying securities and funds that did better than average in the past. This practice demonstrates a naïve hope that such investments will deliver better returns in the future.
The investment industry understands that people naively buy funds because of superior historical performance records. Therefore, they market only their successful funds, and they conveniently leave their laggard funds out of their promotions. The securities industry feeds this frenzy by selectively advertising funds that did better than average in the past. (See: How Morningstar Ratings for mutual funds are used as a marketing tool)
In particular, many investors buy funds based on four star and five star Morningstar Ratings hoping to achieve superior future performance. Unfortunately, there is no reason to believe that these star ratings indicate superior future performance. At best, superior past performance is only a mirage. At worst, chasing it will waste your time and can entice you to pay excessive fees for future gross performance that is likely just to be mediocre before your investment costs, taxes, and time are taken into consideration. Higher fees usually tend to lead to lower net performance. (See: Do mutual fund Morningstar Ratings changes influence individual investors?, Do Morningstar Ratings predict risk-adjusted equity mutual fund performance?, and What might be wrong with buying a mutual fund with a 4 or 5 star Morningstar Rating?)
Very low cost index mutual and exchange-traded funds track the broad markets and tend to deliver better performance after costs and taxes are taken into account. Market index funds will not have “superior” performance, because their objective is to track the market return. Investors need to overcome the false idea that superior past performance is a viable method to select investments. Instead, they need to understand that “mediocre” index mutual funds and ETFs more reliably achieve close to a market return with much less volatility and much lower costs. Therefore, the pursuit of “mediocrity” is a superior strategy, because those who pursue superiority are more likely to end up with inferior net performance — below the mediocrity of the market return. (See: Scientific mutual fund and ETF screening criteria — a summary)
Everyone naturally avoids inferior performance, which in its worst form can be a very slight indicator of inferior future performance. Again, excessive costs are the likely culprit, when highly inferior historical performance persists. (See: Evaluate historical investment performance, but only after using other investment screening criteria)
Finally, beware of any recently discovered alternative “asset class” that is being promoted to you. These include the 31+ flavors of hedge funds, precious metals, managed commodities futures, and other “new asset classes.” Typically, with past hot streak value appreciation as bait, investors are encouraged to allocate a portion of their portfolio to these supposedly new asset classes to earn higher returns with presumably lower overall portfolio risk. The high cost of investing in this new asset class will often be a tip off to problems ahead. Furthermore, when you look closely at the data, past superior performance data often may be highly suspect, and the true risks may be understated substantially.
Tags: poor performance
Personal Financial Planning
- Taking the Snake Oil Out of Mutual Fund Evaluation (Superior mutual fund and ETF performance charts are the sales tools of modern financial snake oil salesmen
Historical performance charts allow investment fund promoters to market selectively their supposedly superior funds and to allege that their excessively high fees are worth it. Lured in by superior past performance, most often individual investors will get mediocre future [...])
- The Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years (
The Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years - Part 1
What could the biggest personal finance story of three decades be?
The growth of mutual funds and ETFs? Nope.
The dot com boom and bust? Nope.
Vanishing pensions? Nope.
The not-so-high quality of mortgage bonds? Nope.
A 0% personal savings rate nationally? [...])
- Factors Favoring Roth IRA and Roth 401k Plan Contributions (Factors that tend to favor Roth IRA and Roth 401k tax-advantaged plan contributions
In a recent article, "Traditional versus Roth tax-advantaged plan contributions," The Skilled Investor discussed why the average taxpayer would tend to benefit more by contributing to traditional rather than to tax-advantaged Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) retirement plans. This follow-up article in two-parts [...])
- American Funds – EuroPacific Growth Fund – Class A Shares (AEPGX) get a +2 Fund Authority Score (The diversified investment fund strategy of American Funds' EuroPacific Growth Fund
According to American Funds' Annual Report for the EuroPacific Growth Fund, the fund "seeks long-term capital appreciation by investing primarily in the securities of companies based in Europe and the Pacific Basin." American Fund's 497 filing on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission EDGAR system [...])
- American Funds – The Investment Company of America – Class A Shares (AIVSX) net a +3 Fund Authority Score (Fund Authority Scores rate mutual funds and exchange traded funds (ETFs) on the most important economic factors that influence individual investors' net long term diversified investment fund performance. The Skilled Investor developed the Fund Authority Score system to provide individual investors with concise and objective summaries of mutual funds and ETFs for comparisons within investment [...])
- Select investments rationally – Step 6 of 10 Financial Planning Steps in the Right Direction (CLICK HERE TO READ THE SKILLED INVESTOR's OTHER ARTICLES ABOUT THESE "10 FINANCIAL PLANNING STEPS IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION
Given the extremely large number and variety of available securities, investors need a rational basis to select among them. Without rational selection criteria and a good understanding of which factors are more or less likely to increase [...])
- Stay Invested in Securities Markets to Earn Risk Premiums (You must stay invested in the securities markets to earn market return risk premiums
Securities markets pay risk premiums to risk takers
You have to have your money invested and at risk to be paid a risk premium. Attempting to avoid risk or losses by jumping in and out to "time the markets" does not work. Scientific [...])
- Avoid Mutual Fund and ETF Sales Commissions and Fees (Avoid mutual funds and ETFs with sales commissions and marketing fees
Summary: There is no convincing evidence that sales loads and other sales fees charged to investors result in higher mutual fund and ETF performance.
In fact, the opposite has repeatedly been proven true with mutual funds, which have a long performance history to evaluate. Paying a [...])
- Hitting the Citibank Stone Wall in Polite Conversation (PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA - Part 4: Hitting the Citibank Stone Wall in Polite Conversation
This article continues my personal saga of trying to get Citibank to fix problems with their management of my credit card account with them.
For a summary of the overall situation, go to Part #1: My Treasure Is Taken!
For an article [...])
- Earned Income Drives the Personal Finances of Most People (Do-It-Yourself Financial Planning - Earned income drives the personal finances of most people
The ability to project your various income sources automatically over your lifetime is one of the first steps in creating a useful do-it-yourself personal financial plan. Whether from wages and salary or from self-employment, personal earned income drives the lifetime finances of most [...])
- Financial Industry Product Development and Your Best Interests (
Financial research drives industry product development, but not necessarily toward the best interests of individuals
Personal financial decisions seem to have become very complicated. To add to the confusion, the financial services industry develops an unending array of supposedly innovative new products. However, a large part of the complexity that individuals face results from the proliferation [...])
- Conclusion to: What Is a Well-Diversified Investment Portfolio? (<<-- Continued from Part 1
In addition to showing that large numbers of additional stocks are required to achieve measurable improvements in diversification, the Evans and Archer study clarified other requirements for a well-diversified portfolio. The number of stocks selected for a highly diversified portfolio also depends on what one actually means by "the market."
To achieve [...])
- Vanguard 500 Index Fund – VFINX – merits the Best +10 Fund Authority Score (The Standard & Poors 500 stock index is the most common equity index fund benchmark in the U.S. The S and P 500 tracks about 75% of publicly traded U.S. equity market asset value. The dominant issue in choosing among passively managed index mutual funds and ETF funds benchmarked against the S & P 500 [...])
- Determine the Savings You Need for Your Lifetime Financial Goals (You cannot invest without savings. How much savings are enough? ... too little? ... too much?
Currently, the U.S. is experiencing a savings crisis. The net personal savings rate is zero or slightly negative, despite a healthy and growing economy. This situation is a prescription for millions upon millions of future personal financial disasters. (See: [...])
- Part 2 of the Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years (< -- Go to Part 1
The Biggest Personal Finance Story of the Past 30 Years - Part 2
To understand what has happened to the market valuation of the financial services sector, particularly over the last 30 years, you should view Figure 4 on page 16 of the financial study by Jeremy Siegel and Jeremy Schwartz [...])