Choose mutual funds and ETFs with a minimum economical portfolio size
If you are going to invest in actively managed funds, then you should want them to have a sufficiently large asset base to fund the necessary research.
If an active fund is too small, then fund management quality can suffer or fees could grow. Index funds do not have the significant overhead that active funds have, which is associated with evaluating investment alternatives. Because of their much lower costs, the minimum size of passively managed index funds can be much less an issue than it is with an actively managed fund.
To amortize the management expenses that are necessary to manage properly an actively managed mutual fund or ETF each year, some minimum total asset figure is required. To illustrate, an actively managed $100M equity mutual fund with a 1% expense ratio yields $1 million annually for management expenses.
In the grand scheme of what it takes to run an actively managed mutual fund or ETF each year, $1M is just not a lot of money. Therefore, it would be reasonable for you to set your minimum asset selection criteria at several hundred million dollars or even higher for an actively managed equity mutual fund.
If your maximum annual management expense screening criterion were lower than 1%, then the required asset base would need to be proportionately higher. If the expenses of a particular “style” of active fund, such as emerging markets equities, tend to be even higher, then you would want an even larger asset base over which to spread active management costs.
While the scientific investment literature indicates that passive index fund strategies lead to better net performance on average, The Skilled Investor does not expect that actively managed funds will disappear. Therefore, if you still are going to invest in actively managed funds, then you should want them to have a sufficiently large asset base to fund the necessary research. If an active fund is too small, then fund management quality could suffer and/or fees could grow.
The problem with active professional fund management is not that there is no “gross” value added. On average, fund management professionals make a positive contribution before their expenses. They may be doing so at the expense of amateurs who are poor portfolio self-managers. (See: What is the cost to individual investors of sub-optimal portfolio diversification?)
The problem with active professional management is that, on average, they charge substantially more than they return in improved performance. The average active managers just does not make a sufficiently great incremental contribution to overcome his added cost, and there is no reliable way to tell future winners versus losers among active professional managers. Therefore, in “net” rather than “gross” terms, it is more likely for active managers to trail a passive market index return.
There are significant differences in costs between actively managed funds and passively managed index funds. By not attempting to beat the market, which most often will meet with failure, index funds can dramatically reduce costs and taxes and improve the odds of better net returns. While there are some areas of specialized expertise in index fund management, properly managing an index mutual fund depends largely on an efficient trading operation to track the index and an efficient customer service back-end.
Index funds do not have the significant overhead that active funds do associated with evaluating investment alternatives. Therefore, the demand for expensive staff is greatly reduced. Because of their much lower costs, the minimum size of passively managed index funds is much less of an issue than it is with actively managed funds. However, you should expect that passively managed index funds will have significantly lower expense ratios. With significantly lower annual expense ratios, index funds still need a reasonably substantial asset base to fund their management costs.
With an index fund, The Skilled Investor suggests that you screen index funds using the maximum expense ratio that you will personally tolerate. If an index fund is run efficiently, then their expense ratio should be very, very low. While there are some ridiculous examples of domestic index funds with expense ratios over 1% annually, even a .25% upper screening limit will give you a wide range of funds from which to choose.
Finally, note that newly created, actively managed funds that are spawned within a larger fund family may benefit for a time from both the fund family’s economies of scale and its subsidies. Administrative economies of scale can permit new funds with smaller asset sizes to exist for a longer period. Often, fund families will also subsidize the expense ratio of their newer funds. This temporarily reduced expense ratio can have the effect of increasing short-term performance. However, if a new fund does not grow quickly, then it is likely to be shut down or merged into an inferior performing and/or more risky fund within that mutual fund family.
Tags:
ETF
Personal Financial Planning
- 10 Lower Cost S and P 500 Index Mutual Funds (
10 Lower Cost S&P 500 Index Mutual Funds
Regular readers know that The Skilled Investor advocates a very boring, low cost, broad market, passive index investment strategy. Costs less. Gets the broad market return -- whatever that will be. Narrows the range of outcomes and therefore the risk to your long-term personal financial plan. Takes far [...])
- Summary Table of Traditional IRA and Roth IRA Tax Rules (
Summary Table of Traditional IRA and Roth IRA Tax Rules
For your convenience, The Skilled Investor has provided a detailed table that summarizes 2007 rules for traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs.
Because this table has 13 columns and 20 rows, it is too large to be displayed properly in a blog posting. To view this table and [...])
- Traditional IRA and 401k Versus Roth IRA and Roth 401k Contributions (
Traditional IRA and 401k versus Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) plan contributions
Many taxpayers puzzle over whether to contribute to traditional versus Roth tax-advantaged retirement plans. For most people, contributions to traditional tax-advantaged plans will probably provide a higher net present value over their lifetimes.
Given our tax-related software modeling capabilities, The Skilled Investor has some observations [...])
- Reduce investment expenses and control taxation – Step 7 of 10 Financial Planning Steps in the Right Direction (CLICK HERE TO READ THE SKILLED INVESTOR's OTHER ARTICLES ABOUT THESE "10 FINANCIAL PLANNING STEPS IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION
Even with optimal investment strategies, there is still substantial room to improve upon net investment performance through continued and vigilant focus on controlling investment costs and tax realization.
The fees extracted by the financial securities industry increased substantially [...])
- 22 Ways to Avoid Financial Advisor and Investment Counselor Frauds and Scams (
Avoiding financial advisor and investment counselor frauds and scams - Overview
The best way to avoid being defrauded or scammed by a financial or investment advisor is to investigate carefully several different advisers before hiring one of them.
If you carefully choose a financial adviser or investment counselor, you have a far greater chance of finding one [...])
- Carnival of Financial Planning – December 27 2007 Edition (Welcome to the December 27, 2007 edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning.
The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus on efficient and sustainable personal financial planning practices that can lead to lifetime financial security. This edition is arranged by subject heading, so that [...])
- A Financial Decision Tool That Becomes Increasingly Valuable Over Time (
As a financial decision tool, VeriPlan becomes increasingly valuable with the passage of time
Summary: While VeriPlan is an genuine bargain because of its low cost, it is an even greater bargain, when you consider that VeriPlan has no built-in obsolescence and that it can be used productively for years. We have engineered VeriPlan, so that [...])
- Screening Index Mutual Funds with IndexUniverse.com (
Screening index mutual funds on-line with IndexUniverse.com
In this article, The Skilled Investor discusses how to screen index mutual funds on-line. This article focuses on using the free index mutual fund screener and database available at IndexUniverse.com.
We also discuss how to apply our seven scientifically based mutual fund screening criteria.
In a previous article, The Skilled Investor [...])
- Avoid Mutual Fund and ETF Sales Commissions and Fees (
Avoid mutual funds and ETFs with sales commissions and marketing fees
Summary: There is no convincing evidence that sales loads and other sales fees charged to investors result in higher mutual fund and ETF performance.
In fact, the opposite has repeatedly been proven true with mutual funds, which have a long performance history to evaluate. Paying a [...])
- Best Financial Investment Articles (
Best Personal Financial Planning and Personal Investment Articles this Week from Personal Finance Blogs
Carnival of Financial Planning - Edition #157 - September 10, 2010
Welcome to the September 10, 2010 Edition #157 of the Carnival of Financial Planning.
The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus [...])
- Benefits of Traditional IRA Contributions for Renters (
Introduction
In a series of articles, The Skilled Investor compares different lifetime financial planning projections for Fran and Fred Frugal to illustrate the relative value of adopting different financial planning strategies. Fran and Fred, both age 30, are a married working couple with $100,000 in combined annual earned income. (See the "Fran and Fred's Baseline Lifetime [...])
- Default under the Citibank Credit Card Contract (PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA - Part 6: Default under the Citibank credit card contract
This final article in this series discusses the seven conditions of default under the Citibank / ATT Universal card agreement.
It also expresses my opinions about contractual relationships in general and about the Citibank / AT&T Universal credit card contract in particular.
For [...])
