Use Caution with Classical Investment Books

Use Caution with Classical Investment Books – A Tip from The Skilled Investor

Individual investors should exercise caution when applying the tactics of classical investment books to current markets. The more handcrafted, seat-of-the-pants, and individual actor approach to the securities markets in the pre-computer, pre-networking era has given way to different practices. What might have worked then may not work now. Do not to confuse valid investment principles with the tactics that were used to implement them in the past.

Securities markets and the financial services industry have changed dramatically in the past several decades. The markets and the industry have been transformed by:

real-time global trading

huge trading volume,

pervasive computer and networking infrastructure,

increased professionalism and an influx of technocrats,

proliferation of investment vehicles,

extremely rapid information dispersion,

automated market data analysis,

sophisticated computerized risk modeling,

invention of derivative securities, and

numerous other factors.

Many classical investment books from the more distant past have been republished and some have retained a significant following. Classical books, such as “Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits” by Philip A. Fisher and “Securities Analysis: Principles and Techniques” by Benjamin Graham and David L. Dodd, to list just two, remain interesting and instructive. However, these authors were writing in a time when the markets were quite different.

For example, scientific finance studies have verified that the value-based investment focus of Graham and Dodd remains valid in modern times. Well-constructed statistical studies indicate that on average over long periods, the markets do seem to provide better total returns to a value-based approach. The importance of value-based investing has been incorporated into investment theory. For example, the multi-factor market return models of scientific investment studies now incorporate a value-versus-growth factor.

While there is truth behind Graham and Dodd’s value-based approach, it is doubtful whether individual investors on their own can now profitably implement tactics that might have worked in the past. It is doubtful whether an individual who diligently analyzes stocks and self-manages his portfolio will obtain superior returns over the long run, when compared to a passive index fund strategy that has a skew toward value investing. Implementing a value strategy through very low-cost mutual funds and exchange-traded funds or ETFs is just more efficient.

Amateurs tend to do a very poor job of building diversified portfolios, and they incur higher investment costs in the process. Furthermore, portfolio self-assembly requires a very large personal time commitment and the opportunity cost of one’s time adds to costs. Compared to the “olden days,” the current securities market environment strongly favors investments by individual investors that are made through low cost mutual funds and ETFs, rather than through direct investments in individual equities.

For information on how poorly individual investors tend to do at portfolio management, see this article: “What is the cost to individual investors of sub-optimal portfolio diversification?”

For articles that will help you understand the requirements of personal portfolio diversification, see these articles: “Diversify Assets” (12 articles)

For articles on the opportunity cost of your personal time spent on investing activities, see these articles: “Personal Efficiency” (4 articles)

For articles on historical market returns and risk premiums, see these articles: “Returns and Risk Premiums” (10 articles)

Click here to get the details about Personal Finance Management Software

Tags: Individual Investors

Personal Financial Planning

• The New Blog Carnival of Financial Planning ( Introducing the Carnival of Financial Planning We spend an extraordinary amount of time earning money and a lot of personal time on backward looking tax and accounting matters. When these tasks are done, how much time and energy do you have left for forward-looking financial planning activities that could improve your future financial welfare? Most people [...])
• Traditional IRA and 401k Versus Roth IRA and Roth 401k Contributions ( Traditional IRA and 401k versus Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) plan contributions Many taxpayers puzzle over whether to contribute to traditional versus Roth tax-advantaged retirement plans. For most people, contributions to traditional tax-advantaged plans will probably provide a higher net present value over their lifetimes. Given our tax-related software modeling capabilities, The Skilled Investor has some observations [...])
• Avoiding Financial Advisor Frauds and Scams – Part 1 ( Part 1 of the The Never-Do List - 22 Good Ways to Avoid Financial Advisor and Investment Counselor Frauds and Scams This article discusses things that you should “never do” with a financial planner or investment advisor, and it covers adviser selection, contracts, signatures, and ownership title of your assets. You should never do certain things with [...])
• Advisor Costs and Strategies Determine Your Return on their Services ( Financial advisor costs and the value of their investment strategies determine your return on investment from these investment advisor services A previous financial article, “The Solution - ONLY follow financial strategies that are scientific, passive, diversified, savings focused, risk controlled, low cost, and tax efficient,” suggested that investors are much better off with a well-considered financial [...])
• Understand Your Lifetime Personal Savings Requirements ( VeriPlan helps you to understand your lifetime personal savings requirements and whether your current savings rate is sufficient How much you earn, spend, and save are by far the most dominant determinants of your long-term financial well-being. You need a means to evaluate your current sustainable lifecycle consumption rate. VeriPlan provides such a means. VeriPlan projects your [...])
• American Funds – EuroPacific Growth Fund – Class A Shares (AEPGX) get a +2 Fund Authority Score ( The diversified investment fund strategy of American Funds' EuroPacific Growth Fund According to American Funds' Annual Report for the EuroPacific Growth Fund, the fund "seeks long-term capital appreciation by investing primarily in the securities of companies based in Europe and the Pacific Basin." American Fund's 497 filing on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission EDGAR system [...])
• Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (VTSMX) achieves a +9 Fund Authority Score ( The diversified investment fund strategy of the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund According to the Vanguard website, the investment strategy of the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index mutual fund is to use a "passive management—or indexing—investment approach designed to track the performance of the MSCI® US Broad Market Index, which represents 99.5% or more of [...])
• How to distinguish between true investment skill and luck ( Even if an investor has obtained superior results over an extended period, is this sufficient proof that these investment results were actually due to skill rather than just a lucky streak? No, these investment results could still be due to chance. For example, take a large population, such as all individual investors in the U.S., and [...])
• Financial Planner and Investment Advisor Compensation Paid by Third Parties ( There are three primary types of third party or commission-based compensation: commission-only, fee-based commission, and fee-offset commission. How an advisor is compensated can be a very important issue. With commission-only advisors, there is no direct cost to the client for planning and advice. The advice appears to be free, but it is not. Most clients find [...])
• Financial Advisor and Investment Counselor Compensation Paid by Clients ( There are three primary types of client paid advisor compensation: hourly-fee, fixed-fee, and asset-fee. When choosing an advisor, individuals should first decide the type of advisor compensation that makes them most comfortable. How an advisor is compensated can be a very important issue. When you hire a financial planner or investment advisor, 1) you pay directly [...])
• The Heavy Burden of Recurring Investment Expenses and Fees – Part 2 ( The heavy burden of recurring investment fees (Part 2 of 2) < < -- Go to Part 1 By charging fees as a percent of your assets, the investment industry can make their recurring fees seem small – like they are “just a few” percent. Furthermore, by charging fees against your assets the industry can still bill you [...])
• August 9 2007 Edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning ( Carnival of Financial Planning - August 9, 2007 Edition Welcome to the August 9, 2007 edition of the Carnival of Financial Planning. The Carnival of Financial Planning takes a long-term view of personal financial planning for individuals and families. We focus on efficient and sustainable personal financial planning practices that can lead to lifetime financial security. This [...])