PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA – Part 3: I want my treasure back!! (Please)
What are my rights in the situation that I summarized in my previous article: “PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA: My Treasure Is Taken!“? Well, the answer is very simple. I have a contractual right to get my treasure back. I also have a right to fair, honest, and ethical treatment.
In this third part of my personal “PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA” saga with Citibank, I make a reasoned, written appeal to the Citibank executive whom I believe is in charge of Citibank’s Jacksonville, Florida credit card operations. In doing so, I received my first evidence of Citibank’s “customer service” stone wall and intransigence. I also received more evidence of Citibank’s administrative incompetence regarding my credit card account.
< <– Go to Part #2: PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA: What are my rights?
A customer comment from the sidebar: "VeriPlan is a big help. I'm in my mid 50's and have been a diligent saver and passable investor for many years. I am going through a work transition from salaried corporate employee to independent consultant, and my aging parents are needing financial help. Financial planning is particularly important to me and my family now. Thanks for making your product available. I've recommended it to a number of folks and will continue to do so." J.H. in Portland, OR
Find Home Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "VeriPlan has been a very flexible home financial planning tool. It took me a few hours on a weekend to understand what VeriPlan could do and to enter our financial data. Our family financial affairs were scattered all over, and we lacked a comprehensive picture of what the future might hold for us. I wanted a clear understanding of our projected lifetime and retirement income, expenses, taxes, debts, real estate, financial assets, college investments, retirement investments, and everything else all together." S. L. in Altadena, CA
Discover Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "You have done a great job of including the necessary instructions in VeriPlan, located close to where the modeling is happening. The thing I like about the VeriPlan User Guide is that it adds substantial additional commentary that I personally find very valuable. I was hunting for a capable and reasonably priced financial planning package, and VeriPlan is an awesome tool. The more I play around with it, the more valuable I find it. Your free user guide was what made me decide to get VeriPlan." C. A. in North Royalton, OH
Financial Planning Software for Individuals
A customer comment from the sidebar: "One of the stories that VeriPlan tells me is how much of my money could be lost to excessive investment costs. I just switched to some lower cost funds in my 401k. I loved updating VeriPlan with the new cost values just to see the red bar on the Total Assets chart get significantly thinner - quite a shocking difference." M. W. in Tulsa, OK
The Best DIY Retirement Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I am extremely impressed with the depth of information that VeriPlan asks for and provides. VeriPlan seems much more detailed than one would expect for the very reasonable price. Although I am not a financial professional, I consider myself more financially educated than the most people of my age (62). I find that VeriPlan's depth to be just what we need for our retirement planning. I am glad I purchased it. Thanks." J. W. in Gainsville, FL
Financial Planning Software for Consumers
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I have been very happy with this software. I will put VeriPlan to work to help optimize our IRA to Roth conversions, while avoiding the IRMAA penalties if we can. We are in an opportunistic window for the next several years. I have been appalled by the lack of professional knowledge available with respect to the tax burden that will fall upon us when RMDs take effect. Most of the information I have found suggests that it isn't a problem. Luckily, this software will be of great benefit to chart our course." J. S. in Louisville, KY
Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I am a recently retired engineer, and I created a cash flow Excel spreadsheet for 25 years of retirement. So, I fully appreciate the data and potential variances that must be accounted for. Yet, mine is so very simple compared to VeriPlan. I love VeriPlan's concept of total control over inputs and parameters. Veriplan's objectives are very much like mine, but it has many, many more input and control options, and the price is spot on." L. G. in Southbridge, VA
Family Financial Planning Software for Consumers
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I've been using VeriPlan for a few weeks now, and it is everything I was looking for plus a whole lot more of what I didn't even know I needed. By simply switching VeriPlan to a state that does not have a state income tax, I can see how much I could save on traditional IRA distributions in retirement by moving to a state without income taxes. It is a real education in personal finance, and I think just about everyone would benefit from using this tool." T. H. in Silicon Valley CA
Financial Planning and Retirement Software for Home Use
Go to Part #4: Hitting the Citibank Stone Wall in Polite Conversation –>>
Okay, Citibank had decided to refund two months of their excessive interest rate charges and had reset my loan interest rate for the 32.31% default interest rate back to the 2.99% special interest rate. Resetting the interest rate did not matter, because my wire transfer had paid the loan balance in full. I no longer owed anything to Citibank on this credit card account. Instead, they owed me.
However, Citibank was still holding on to 4 more months of excessive and unjustified default interest rate charges. I knew that I had to write a letter to recover my treasure. The only name I had was Citibank Vice President and General Manager, Julie A. Garry. I thought that if I explained the situation to her, she would be reasonable, and see that Citibank had made mistakes in putting my account into default.
A customer comment from the sidebar: "VeriPlan's financial projection graphics simply lay out what the future might hold for my family. Also, VeriPlan is a very fast and automated financial investment calculator that allows me to change anything and to test alternate investment decisions rapidly. Its integrated documentation explains clearly how it works, and it also includes a wealth of well-researched personal finance and investment information that has been very helpful." T. F. in Muncie, IN
Find Home Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I do most of my own financial modeling, and I like the way VeriPlan generates “what if” scenarios that I like to compare, such as possibly buying a rental property, selling my house and renting, moving social security retirement age payment timing, and pulling out IRA money after taxes. Plus, I like VeriPlan for its automated projection of detailed investment costs. Thanks for making a great product." K. W. in Naperville, IL
Discover Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I am 10 years out from retirement, and I needed to start thinking more seriously about having enough to retire on. I'm following the suggestions of you and others in opting for more hands-on retirement planning. I am also using lower cost index investing. There are too many wealth management companies out there, all ready to charge an arm and leg for what should be straightforward financial planning work." G. B. in Smith Mountain Lake, VA
Financial Planning Software for Individuals
A customer comment from the sidebar: "Larry, Hello again! I've continued to work with VeriPlan, and the more I work with it the more I'm amazed at how much it does. It's an incredible decision support tool for my financial planning. Since I have already built a model of my lifetime finances, it is easy to test new ideas as they come to me. Thanks again." M. W. R. in Austin, TX
Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I first learned about the zero federal taxes on long term capital gains when under the 25% marginal income tax rate from working with VeriPlan a number of years ago. I’m no longer working but not yet receiving RMD’s or social security so my ordinary income is relatively low. So I’ve been taking full advantage of zero federal capital gains taxes by selling off my high expense ratio mutual funds which have a lot of capital gains built in since I’ve held them a long time and then I reinvest them in index mutual funds which don’t generate as much capital gains distributions. So the education that you and VeriPlan provide has saved me thousands in taxes, not to mention the expenses on high cost mutual funds. Thanks again." M. D. in El Paso, TX
Family Financial Planning Software for Consumers
I wrote a polite and detailed five page letter to Ms. Garry explaining the situation. Three pages of this letter provided a chronology of events over the past year, which clearly demonstrated my continuing adherence to the terms of the credit card agreement. (See Part #1 for a summary of these events.)
Two weeks later, I received a cryptic letter signed by an “S. Larson” of Customer Service. We had had other communications previously from S. Larson, when we tried unsuccessfully for four months last year to set up automatic payments on this account. This S. Larson informed me that “after further review, we have determined that your account is not eligible for a credit of the finance charges.” That was it. There was no explanation of why Citibank was justified in having done what it did. Those 19 words erased all the goodwill that I had personally built up in carrying my AT&T Universal Card for over 15 years.
(While Citibank did this, I have to keep reminding myself that AT&T is not an active party to this, even though AT&T’s brand is all over the written communications about this credit card. Without careful examination, most people would conclude that these were AT&T’s policies, because this is an AT&T “affinity” credit card that I have had for about 15 years as a “charter member”.)
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I am a recently retired engineer, and I created a cash flow Excel spreadsheet for 25 years of retirement. So, I fully appreciate the data and potential variances that must be accounted for. Yet, mine is so very simple compared to VeriPlan. I love VeriPlan's concept of total control over inputs and parameters. Veriplan's objectives are very much like mine, but it has many, many more input and control options, and the price is spot on." L. G. in Southbridge, VA
Find Home Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "Thanks for developing a great product. I have looked at Money Tree, Money Guide Pro, and some other FP software, and I have used Right Capital (a good product also, but still $100 per month). Yours is just as robust for a much more affordable price. I also extensively use Quicken for my finances, but the planning tool in it is kind of basic, so VeriPlan will complement Quicken very well." E. Z. in San Mateo, CA
Discover Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I spent parts of the past several days entering data into the VeriPlan workbook while digesting as much of the methodology as possible. My takeaway is that VeriPlan is an extraordinary tool, especially in its ability to generate projections based on detailed alternate scenarios. During the learning process, I also found it to be a wonderful financial education in its own right." S. N. in Sammamish, WA
Financial Planning Software for Individuals
A customer comment from the sidebar: "Previously I used some consumer retirement planners like New Retirement. What they offer is a projection of your financial situation that is wildly generalized. A generalized projection is probably better than having no projection at all and could very well be used for rough, long-term planning. However, for fine grained planning, such a system is wholly inadequate. VeriPlan is vastly superior in comprehensiveness and flexibility." T. D. in Edison, NJ
Family Financial Planning Software
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I purchased VeriPlan for the Roth conversion features. I enjoy VeriPlan and appreciate the thoroughness of the design and excellent commentary. I now work for (financial company name redacted) since retiring from (computer company name redacted) in a Retirement and Workplace Planning role. The accuracy, conciseness, and utility of the information presented by VeriPlan is great." M. S. in White Plains, NY
Family Financial Planning Software for Home Use
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I've been using VeriPlan for a few weeks now, and it is everything I was looking for plus a whole lot more of what I didn't even know I needed. By simply switching VeriPlan to a state that does not have a state income tax, I can see how much I could save on traditional IRA distributions in retirement by moving to a state without income taxes. It is a real education in personal finance, and I think just about everyone would benefit from using this tool. I am going to tell everyone I know about VeriPlan. Thank you very much for creating it. Your web sites are great, too." T. H. in Silicon Valley CA
Financial Planning and Retirement Software for Home Use
A customer comment from the sidebar: "I thought I would let you know that VeriPlan was the primary decision support tool in my decision to retire early, which was about 4 years ago now. And it has worked out really well. Since then I got married, and we have traveled to 10 countries -- some on mission trips. I had used the lifetime planners in Microsoft Money and Quicken but they were not robust enough to make a major decision with. In retrospect they are toys compared to VeriPlan. So VeriPlan has been a very big help to me. Also, I recently read your Lowest Cost Mutual Funds book, which was great. It brought a few things to my attention that I need to work on." Email update from T. H. in Silicon Valley
Family Financial Planning and Retirement Software
By the way, I said in Part 1 that I would give any person involved in this saga who was not a VP or higher, a pseudonym like “Deckhand Moe” or “First Mate Shemp.” However, I will use the name S. Larson, because I have found out that most, if not all, letters to customers from Citibank’s Customer Service Operation are signed by S. Larson in typeface with a human signature script underneath. I have also found out that this credit card operation has 30,000 employees. That is a lot of S. Larson letters.
In talking to “First Mate Shemp” at Citibank, I learned that S. Larson is not even flesh and blood, despite the human signature. My wife had corresponded with S. Larson several times in her efforts to set up the failed automated payments that lead us into this mess. My wife thought she was dealing with a human being. It turns out that my wife was corresponding with a machine — and not a very competent one at that. From here on, I will call this the “S. Larson machine,” which I have come to understand is just a part of Citibank’s computer infrastructure. It appears that the S. Larson machine is not very accurate.
The remaining few sentences of this rejection letter from the S. Larson machine said that I could use my credit balance “towards future purchases or cash advances,” or I could “request that a refund check be sent” to me. This part of the Citibank appeal rejection letter was very curious to me. I had written a thoughtful and detailed letter to Julie A. Garry, Vice President and General Manager. (I still believe that Ms. Garry is a human being, but I cannot be 100% certain at this point, because I have not heard back from her.)
The letter I wrote had taken my valuable time, and I had made an effort to be clear, informative, and accurate. I attempted to provide Ms. Garry with that information that I thought would aid her in her decision, once she verified the facts that I had supplied. I did not really believe necessarily that Ms. Garry would personally review my appeal, but I did expect that she might delegate the matter to a subordinate who would deal with my case fairly and competently.
I really do hope that a competent human being actually did review my appeal letter to reach Citibank’s decision. However, I have no clue about what actually transpired in Citibank’s decision process. When any company says “no” without explanation in response to a reasoned and factual letter, it is easy for an outsider/customer to conclude that they either do not have a good reason to say no or that they just do not care.
In response to my efforts to appeal, apparently a machine had written back to me. In doing so, this Citibank S. Larson machine had determined that I was not eligible for a refund. However, the S. Larson machine also told me that I had a substantial positive credit balance in my account (which was for Citibank’s refund of two month of excessive default interest rate charges). The S. Larson machine also wrote that I could make future purchases or even get a cash advance for this credit balance by using my AT&T Universal credit card.
Now, this does seem like rather odd advice, since Vice President Garry had written to me twice about a year ago to tell me that all AT&T Universal accounts were closed and that I could NOT make any further purchases, and I could NOT get any cash advances on my card. I doubted the truth of what the S. Larson machine had written to me, but the S. Larson machine had chosen print this cryptic rejection letter and this apparently bad advice on “AT&T Universal Card” letterhead. Apparently, the S. Larson machine was giving me directives specifically for the AT&T Universal card and not just any generic Citibank credit card. Citibank was telling me to do things that contradicted their prior written instructions. At a minimum in my situation and opinion, I have come to believe that Citibank’s credit card operations have demonstrated evidence of repeated incompetence.
So, what really is true? Has my closed AT&T Universal card account really been reopened for charges and cash advances? Had any competent human being at Citibank really reviewed any of the particulars of my appeal in good faith? Or, had somebody just said: “not – within – the – 60 – day – Fair – Credit – Billing – Act – window — hit – the – S. – Larson – machine – reject – button — no – explanation – required — (and perhaps) — the – facts – of – the – matter – are – not – relevant.”
Having lost all faith in Citibank. Therefore, I took the third point of advice from the S. Larson machine’s letter about what to do with my credit card balance. I wrote to get a partial refund of my money. While I still expect to recover the rest of my treasure, I no longer even have any faith that Citibank will keep to its stated agreement to refund the credit balance that they say that I already have. In my letter requesting a partial credit payout, I asked that Citibank’s credit card operations to leave a credit balance on the account of $18.17. It will be interesting to see whether Citibank will be able to execute this refund, as I have requested.
Next: PIRATES OF THE CREDIT SEA: Hitting the Citibank Stone Wall in Polite Conversation
Related Personal and Retirement Financial Planning Articles
